In the same way my barely legible teenage penmanship has deteriorated across a quarter-century of PC word processing, my instincts to stop and save a game diminished. I attribute this to the emergence of automatic saving, checkpoints, Xbox Quick Resume, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I feel compelled to save every two seconds for fear of catastrophic failure. But I’m not perfect. I become complacent. And this week, I learned a crucial piece of wisdom after significant time invested in the recently released Pokémon FireRed on the Switch: you still gotta manually hit save.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with one of the 2D Pokémon games — as I skipped the Game Boy Advance, 2000’s Pokémon Gold and Silver probably were the final core Pokémon game I completed. Consequently, I was thrilled to pony up the asking price for the sentimental journey to the Kanto region, and an attempt gathering those first 151 pocket monsters. I immediately snapped back to my youth. Over a few successive evenings, I was catching bugs, picked up an early Pikachu, beat Brock on my first turn, took a chance on purchasing the future Gyarados from the salesman in the Pokémon Center, and traversed Mt. Moon completely unconcerned.
The critical error: Not once did I save! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
Jigglypuff will never find love with my Mankey.
Everything went wrong on a night where I didn’t play FireRed… and when my child grabbed the Switch for a quick half-hour of the latest game instead, closing my game in the process. As any Switch user understands (a fact I foolishly ignored…) launching a different title on the console will close your current game. Your data is only preserved if the game autosaved or you saved manually prior to changing games. My mistake.
The Progression of Game Saves: From Deliberate to Seamless
One could view autosave, now so seamless most players barely notice it, as a bona fide “cutting-edge” breakthrough. While PC text adventure Zork implemented a pioneering save functions in a game, the original NES Legend of Zelda is frequently recognized as a landmark achievement for alleviating the sensation of being completely screwed by an in-game fail because of cartridge-based saving on the classic console. Obviously, the onus was still on you to save. (And after one flub), it was a mistake made only once. During the nineties, memory cards on consoles including the original PlayStation normalized the save process but remained precarious; neglecting to save (or misplacing a memory card) could wipe hours of progress. Titles such as Resident Evil took it further by transforming saving into an item to be managed.
Today's automatic saving, which suppressed my instinct to save my Pokémon adventure like a dope, took hold at the dawn of a new century. The original Halo pioneered seamless respawn points while Call of Duty perfected the mechanic to ease frustration and remove unnecessary grinding. As experiences became more vast — and increasingly non-linear — developers solved the puzzle of persistent, invisible saving and, in time, the ultimate convenience of instant on/off.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Funny enough, the world of Pokémon serves as a perfect mirror of that historical progression. For a long time, saving in a Pokémon game required a manual command: fans were taught to manually record their data prior to shutting off their Game Boy or DS. A major change arrived in Pokémon Sword and Shield on Switch, Game Freak implemented an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), representing a substantial attitude adjustment for one of gaming’s most tradition-bound franchises.
I own up to my blunder: A long tenure with Breath of the Wild and contemporary Nintendo titles completely dulled my saving discipline. I still know better with certain games — I won’t even gamble bailing mid-run in something like Hades 2 although I know full well it autosaves after chambers — however, perhaps due to my extended absence from older game design, or I’ve just been spoiled, it didn’t even occur to me to manually save before redocking. My younger self would never have fumbled to this degree.
The Aftermath: Starting From Scratch
I have not opened FireRed following the great progress wipe. When I loaded it back up and discovered my team consisted solely of Squirtle on my roster, a wave of exhaustion hit me. My personal status: Burned.
Perhaps I'll restart… or perhaps I'll remain in the hundreds of new games available now which gently presume I need my hand held. However, my fondness for older titles isn’t dead. On occasions when I can convince my kid to pause auto-saving Pokémon Legends: Z-A, we have been cooperatively playing a collection of classic Bomberman games. Those early SNES games omitted saving entirely opting instead for lengthy password codes. So, even if I make a fatal mistake, it’s not a total loss. That provides some small solace.